HEC-RAS Ineffective Flow Areas

HEC‑RAS Ineffective Flow Areas

Ineffective flow areas allow the user to define areas of the cross section that will contain water that are not actively being conveyed. Ineffective flow areas are often used to describe portions of a cross section in which water will pond, but the velocity of that water, in the downstream direction, is close to zero. This water is included in the storage calculations and other wetted cross section parameters, but it is not included as part of the active flow area. When using ineffective flow areas, no additional wetted perimeter is added to the active flow area.

Ineffective flow areas often occur near roadway crossings when water levels exceed the channel banks and when water cannot flow in the longitudinal direction along the overbank areas due to roadway fill.  When this occurs, flow must contract to pass through the opening under the roadway adding additional and often significant losses.  However, if the roadway overtops, flow becomes possible in the overbank areas as well as in the main channel.

The below figure illustrates the ineffective flow areas upstream and downstream of a roadway crossing.

Bridge Opening Ineffective Flow Areas

Ineffective Flow Area Types

There are two types of ineffective flow areas available:

  • Normal ineffective flow areas
  • Multiple blocks ineffective flow areas

Ineffective flow areas are defined in the Cross Section Data dialog box, in the Ineffective Flow Areas panel.

Cross Section Data dialog box - Ineffective Flow Areas panel

Normal Ineffective Flow Areas

Normal ineffective flow areas allow the user to define a left station and elevation and a right station and elevation for the ineffective flow area. When this type is used, and if the water surface is below the established ineffective elevations, the areas to the left of the left station and to the right of the right station are considered ineffective. Once the water surface goes above either of the established elevations, then that specific area is no longer considered ineffective and flow is considered to be conveyed.

Cross Section Plot - Normal Ineffective Flow Areas

Multiple Blocks Ineffective Flow Areas

Multiple blocks ineffective flow areas allow the user to define up to 20 individual blocks. With this type of ineffective flow area, the user enters a left station, a right station, and an elevation for each of the blocks. An example of a cross section with multiple blocked ineffective flow areas is shown below. Once the water surface goes above the elevation of the blocked ineffective flow area, the blocked area is no longer considered ineffective.

Cross Section Plot - Multiple Blocks Ineffective Flow Areas

Permanent Ineffective Flow Areas

An option is available to make the defined ineffective flow area “permanent” where it does not change into effectively carrying flow when the computed water surface elevation is above the defined ineffective flow area elevation.

This option is generally used only for unsteady flow models to dampen the oscillation that can occur when the software is attempting to converge to a water surface elevation and the computed water surface elevation is iterating and advancing simulation time steps. For example, if the computed water surface elevation is just above the defined ineffective flow area elevation for one time step, and then in the next time step the computed water surface elevation is just below the defined elevation, the available effective flow area will begin to oscillate. This may cause the unsteady flow computations to fail to converge to a solution. By making the ineffective flow areas “permanent”, this ineffective flow area oscillation is eliminated.

Defining Ineffective Flow Areas

The user can use the Cross Section Data dialog box to manually define the ineffective flow areas by selecting horizontal stations and elevations for each of the ineffective flow areas. The user can select the horizontal stations from either the Map View or from the displayed cross section plot.

Alternatively, the user can utilize GIS polyline or polygon data to define ineffective flow areas. Select Input | Assign Entities | Assign Ineffective Flow Areas to display the Assign Ineffective Flow Areas dialog box.

Assign Ineffective Flow Areas dialog box

From this dialog box, the user can select GIS polyline or polygon data to define the ineffective flow areas.

About the Author Chris Maeder

Chris Maeder

Chris is an experienced civil engineering and software technology leader, with over 30 years industry experience. With proven expertise in global software development, he has built engineering teams that adapt quickly, focus on what’s important and, most importantly, deliver. He is a licensed professional civil engineer with extensive experience in water resource engineering. He has performed and supervised engineering projects in urban stormwater drainage, transportation and roadway drainage, storm sewer design, detention pond design, stormwater quality, green infrastructure, watershed management planning, wastewater sewers, water distribution networks, pump stations, FEMA flood studies, bridge and culvert design, bridge scour and armoring, dam failure analysis, seepage and groundwater modeling, and environmental permits.

Related Articles